Preserving Pennsylvania’s Affordable Housing
Pennsylvania could lose tens of thousands of affordable housing units in the next decade, exacerbating cost-of-living challenges in the states, according to a new Housing Initiative at Penn report.
Stuart Weitzman School of Design
102 Meyerson Hall
210 South 34th Street
Philadelphia, PA 19104
Pennsylvania could lose tens of thousands of affordable housing units in the next decade, exacerbating cost-of-living challenges in the states, according to a new Housing Initiative at Penn report.
Michael Grant
mrgrant@design.upenn.edu
215.898.2539
There is not a state in the US that has enough affordable homes to meet the needs of its lowest-income residents. Pennsylvania is in the middle of the pack, with about 39 affordable and available homes for every 100 extremely low-income households, according to the National Low Income Housing Coalition. That problem has spurred recent action from the state government to invest in affordable housing for people of all income levels.
A related problem is that many of the existing federally-funded affordable homes are aging.
A new report from the Housing Initiative at Penn illuminates the challenge. Nearly 3,000 rental properties in Pennsylvania, accounting for more than 180,000 individual apartments, are supported by federal tax credits and other programs. About a third of those, more than 43,000 units in all, have affordability requirements that are scheduled to expire between 2027 and 2036. Even with new federally supported affordable-housing units becoming available, the state will have much less affordable housing in a decade than it does now if all the affordability of those units are not preserved.
“Preserving the affordability of the housing that already exists in the state is a key part to any broader agenda around reducing housing costs,” says Vincent Reina, a professor in the Department of City and Regional Planning and founder of the Housing Initiative at Penn (HIP). HIP has worked with cities and states around the US to advance evidence-based policymaking, and completed a comprehensive statewide housing study for the Pennsylvania Housing Finance Agency in 2020 and 2023.
(Photo: Eric Sucar for Penn Today)
The recent report compiles data on federally-supported affordable-housing units in all 67 Pennsylvania counties. Most of those units are supported either by the Section 8 contracts, which helps low-income tenants pay for market-rate rents, or by Low- Income Housing Tax Credits, which subsidizes new construction of income-restricted units. Traditional public housing accounts for less than a quarter of subsidized units in the state.
The Low-Income Housing Tax Credit program was created in the late 1980s and requires that funded units remain income-restricted for 30 years. Many of the early projects built under that program are reaching the end of their affordability requirements. Owners of those projects can reapply for additional tax credits, but such credits are often awarded on a competitive basis. Projects in high-demand urban areas are likelier to become unrestricted than those in lower-demand rural areas—meaning areas with fast-rising housing costs are also the most vulnerable to losing existing low-income units.
The federal government’s approach to funding affordable housing is in flux. Since the 1980s it has pulled away from funding traditional public housing. President Joe Biden proposed an expansion of the Housing Choice Voucher Program, which is only big enough to support about a quarter of the tenants who are qualified to receive vouchers, but that expansion didn’t come to pass. Last year the Trump administration’s One Big Beautiful Bill Act included a major expansion of the Low-Income Housing Tax Credit program. Reina hopes that the new report shows officials where they should invest their time and resources to preserve as many affordable homes as they can.
“At the end of the day I think it’s going to be a mix of state and local work to assess what the best plan of action is going forward,” he says. “Because some of this is really on a deal-by-deal basis.”