Thesis: Zionts

Thesis: Sophie Zionts

The “Threat” of District Designation: Preservation or Gentrification?

In the summer of 2002, controversy erupted when community groups in West Philadelphia, led by the Spruce Hill Community Association and the University City Historical Society, launched a campaign to designate the neighborhood known as Spruce Hill as a historic district. Designation supporters envisioned that this would protect the unique collection of Victorian domestic architecture for which the West Philadelphia “trolley car suburb” was celebrated.

Victorian twin houses, representative of the architecture prevalent around Spruce Hill that warranted the significance for nomination. PC: Sophie Zionts.

More Victorian style twins. PC: Sophie Zionts.
Designation opponents feared that this would encourage gentrification in the neighborhood, raise property values and force out residents who could not afford to maintain their homes to preservation standards. Designation opponents succeeded in suspending the nomination, thereby effectively killing it. A key opponent in this saga was District 3 Councilwoman Jannie Blackwell, a staunch political figure who attempted twice to take the Philadelphia Historical Commission’s jurisdiction. Ironically, in the two decades since that campaign, Spruce Hill has become one of the most gentrified – and threatened—neighborhoods in the city of Philadelphia.
A pamphlet made in favor of the historic district advertising a public meeting, created by the UCHS and SHCA in 2002. From the Philadelphia Historical Commission physical archive, located at 1515 Arch Street.

A pamphlet made against the historic district by Councilwoman Blackwell’s office, advertising that community members should contact the PHC against designation. From the Philadelphia Historical Commission physical archive, located at 1515 Arch Street.
This thesis aims to examine the extent to which people outside the historic preservation profession associate historic preservation and district designation with gentrification, and how politics may have contributed to the defeat of the Spruce Hill designation effort. Through the analysis of scholarship, news media, and interviewing key individuals, this thesis looks at the relationship between politics and preservation within the case study of Spruce Hill. It examines the pressures that exist between different political branches of local government, and the implications of a historic district, along with the perceptions of how preservation functions in Philadelphia, as well as how some people believe it should function.

Thesis: Sophie Zionts

The “Threat” of District Designation: Preservation or Gentrification?

Students

Faculty